What fails first in a galvanised tank
Galvanising is a zinc coating that protects the steel beneath it. It depletes over time, fastest where water is soft or where the tank is old and the coating has been damaged. Once the steel is exposed it corrodes, producing rust and pitting. The pitting eventually perforates the base or sides, usually at the seams and around the outlet.
Lids, screens, insulation and ball valves often fail before the tank body does. Those are cheap to replace and worth doing on their own.
When refurbishment makes sense
Relining is usually the right answer when the structure is sound — no significant perforation, no distortion, seams and stays intact — and only the internal surface and fittings are degraded. A properly prepared and coated tank has a smooth, approved surface that is easier to clean, and it costs a fraction of replacement.
- Structure sound, corrosion surface-level only
- Tank location difficult to change (roof voids, listed buildings, tight plant rooms)
- Multiple tanks where replacement would mean significant downtime
- Budget constrained but water quality must be restored now
When replacement is the better decision
Replace when the tank is perforated or distorted, when the supporting structure is compromised, when access makes coating impossible to apply to the required standard, or when the tank capacity is wrong for the building anyway — an undersized or oversized tank is an opportunity to correct the design rather than preserve it. A coating applied to a tank that is already failing is money spent on a short life.
How to decide rationally
Ask for a condition survey with photographs, an assessment of remaining life for each option, and a like-for-like comparison of what each delivers: relining restores the internal surface but not the capacity, the access or the supporting steelwork. Once those are laid out side by side, the decision is usually straightforward — and any contractor who will only quote for one option is telling you something.
This article is general guidance, not a site-specific risk assessment. Control measures for your building should follow your written scheme of control and the Approved Code of Practice L8 with HSG274.